Posted on Leave a comment

Hurling-Shinty Internationals Ireland v Scotland 1988-1999

Camanachd Association (Shinty) Logo
Camanachd Association (Shinty) Logo [Reference: 2]

Results

DateVenueHome TeamAway Team
1988Bught ParkScotland4Ireland6
1989Croke ParkIreland4Scotland5
1990Bught ParkScotland5Ireland3
1991Pairc an GaelIreland6Scotland6
1992Bught ParkScotland3Ireland6
1993Bught ParkScotland4Ireland2
1994AthenryIreland3Scotland3
1995Fort WilliamScotland5Ireland4
1996ClareIreland0-10 (10)Scotland3-8 (17)
1997Croke ParkIreland1-9 (12)Scotland3-8 (17)
1998Scotland0-12 (12)Ireland0-7 (7)
1999Scotland3-6 (15)Ireland2-1 (7)
Hurling-Shinty Internationals Ireland v Scotland 1988-1999 [Reference: 1-3]
GAA Logo [Reference: 1]
GAA Logo [Reference: 1]

Report

The Hurling-Shinty International Series between Ireland and Scotland, which had been discontinued in 1980, was revived in 1988. The first five encounters were fairly evenly matched, and Ireland split the series 2-2 with Scotland, with one drawn match. From then on Scotland took over, winning 6 of the next seven encounters, with one tie, despite the scoring system changing from goals only to goals (3 Points) and overs (1 point) in 1996, which should have given Ireland an advantage as the Scottish game is played mostly on the gounnd with no overs. It was said in one report in the Irish Independent in 1999, that the Irish failed to care enough. With a new millennium dawning a new approach was necessary from Ireland, it was said.

About Hurling-Shinty International Rules

Hurling-Shinty International Rules, also known as Compromise Rules, is a game featuring as its name suggests a compromise between the two codes of Gaelic Hurling: Irish Hurling (15-a-side and Points over the bar as well as goals) and Scottish Shinty (12-a-side, Goals only). currently the sport is 14-a-side with both goals and points over tha bar counting, although in the past 13-a-side has been used, as well numerous scoring systems, such as Goals-and-points, Goals-only, Goals-and-Points-with-a-double-score-for-a-Scottish-Shinty-Point (Shinty is played on the ground, giving Hurling, which is played through the air an advantage in points); and Goals-Points-And-Behinds (worth 6 points, 3 Points and 1 Point respectively as opposed to 3 points for a goal an one for a point usually).There is also a Camogie-Shinty version of the game for Women.

Venues

VenueLocation
AthenryCo. Galway, Ireland
Bught ParkInverness, Highlands, Scotland
Croke ParkDublin, Ireland
ClareIreland
Fort WilliamHighlands, Scotland
Pairc an GaelLimerick, Ireland

References

Logos

[1] Pinterest (2020) GAA Logo [Internet] Available from: https://i.pinimg.com/564x/dd/fb/a4/ddfba4a8da99008f3d9008846b0dd8a3.jpg [Accessed 6 December 2020]

[2] Camanachd Association (2017) Camanachd Association Logo [Internet] https://www.shinty.com/uploads/news-images/_w800fit/camanach-logo-wide.jpg [Accessed 9 March 2018]

Sources

[3] Anon. (1998) “The series, the results”. Kilkenny People, Friday, March 13, 1998. pg. 42.

[4] Anon. (1998) “All The Results”. Kilkenny People. Friday, March 20, 1998. pg. 17.

[5] Anon. (1999) “Irish fail to care enough”. Irish Independent. Monday, March 15, 1999. Pg, 46.

Copies of the Irish Independent & Kilkenny People are available to view online at http://www.irishnewsarchive.com which is a subscription service.

Acknowledgements

Thanks to Roisin NicDhonnacha.

About this document

Researched, compiled and written by Enda Mulcahy for the

Eirball | GAA World Archive

Last Updated: 6 December 2020

(c) Copyright Enda Mulcahy and Eirball 2019-2020

You may quote this document in part provided that proper acknowledgement is given to the authors. All Rights Resereved.

Leave a Reply